Attacks on humanitarians are attacks on humanity | Vincent Cochetel | TEDxPlaceDesNations


Translator: Joseph Geni
Reviewer: Ivana Korom I cannot forget them. Their names were Aslan, Alik, Andrei, Fernanda, Fred, Galina, Gunnhild, Hans, Ingeborg, Matti, Natalya, Nancy, Sheryl, Usman, Zarema, and the list is longer. For many, their existence, their humanity, has been reduced to statistics, coldly recorded as “security incidents.” For me, they were colleagues belonging to that community
of humanitarian aid workers that tried to bring a bit of comfort to the victims of the wars
in Chechnya in the ’90s. They were nurses, logisticians,
shelter experts, paralegals, interpreters. And for this service, they were murdered, their family torn apart, and their story largely forgotten. No one was ever sentenced
for these crimes. I cannot forget them. They live in me somehow, their memories giving me meaning everyday. But they are also haunting
the dark street of my mind. As humanitarian aid workers, they made the choice
to be at the side of the victim, to provide some assistance,
some comfort, some protection, but when they needed
protection themselves, it wasn’t there. When you see the headlines
of your newspaper these days with the war in Iraq or in Syria, “Aid worker abducted,” “Hostage executed,” but who were they? Why were they there? What motivated them? How did we become
so indifferent to these crimes? This is why I am here today with you. We need to find better ways
to remember them. We also need to explain the key values to which
they dedicated their lives. We also need to demand for justice. When in ’96, I was sent by the United Nations High Commissioner
for Refugees to the North Caucasus, I knew some of the risks. Five colleagues had been killed, three had been seriously injured, seven had already been taken hostage. So we were careful. We were using
armored vehicles, decoy cars, changing patterns of traveling,
changing homes, all sorts of security measures. Yet on a cold winter night
of January ’98, it was my turn. When I entered my flat
in Vladikavkaz with a guard, we were surrounded by armed men. They took the guard,
they put him on the floor, they beat him up in front of me, tied him, dragged him away. I was handcuffed, blindfolded,
and forced to kneel, with the silencer of a gun
pressed against my neck. When it happens to you, there is no time for thinking,
no time for praying. My brain went on automatic, rewinding quickly
the life I just left behind. It took me long minutes to figure out that those masked men
were not there to kill me, but that someone, somewhere,
had ordered my kidnapping. Then a process of dehumanization
started that day. I was no more than just a commodity. I normally don’t talk about this,
but I’d like to share a bit with you some of those 317 days of captivity. I was kept in an underground cellar, total darkness, for 23 hours and 45 minutes every day, and then the guards
would come, normally two. They would bring a big piece of bread, a bowl of soup, and a candle. That candle would burn for 15 minutes, 15 minutes of precious light, and then they would take it away,
and I returned to darkness. I was chained by a metal cable to my bed. I could do only four small steps. I always dreamt of the fifth one. And no TV, no radio, no newspaper,
no one to talk to. I had no towel, no soap, no toilet paper, just two metal buckets, open, one for water, for one waste. Can you imagine that mock execution
can be a pastime for guards when they are sadistic or when they are just bored or drunk? We are breaking my nails very slowly. Isolation and darkness
are particularly difficult to describe. How do you describe nothing? There are no words for the depths
of loneliness I reached in that very thin border
between sanity and madness. In the darkness, sometimes,
I played imaginary games of checkers. I would start with the black, play with the white, back to the black,
trying to trick the other side. I don’t play checkers anymore. I was tormented
by the thoughts of my family and my colleague, the guard, Edik. I didn’t know what had happened to him. I was trying not to think. I tried to fill up my time by doing all sorts
of physical exercises on the spot. I tried to pray, I tried all sorts
of memorization games. But darkness also creates images
and thoughts that are not normal. One part of your brain wants you
to resist, to shout, to cry, and the other part of the brain
orders you to shut up and just go through it. It’s a constant internal debate;
there is no one to arbitrate. Once a guard came to me,
very aggressively, and he told me, “Today you’re going to kneel
and beg for your food.” I wasn’t in a good mood,
so I insulted him. I insulted his mother,
I insulted his ancestor. The consequence was moderate:
he threw the food into my waste. The day after, he came back
with the same demand. He got the same answer, which had the same consequence. Four days later,
the body was full of pain. I didn’t know hunger hurt so much
when you have so little. So when the guards came down — I knelt. I begged for my food. Submission was the only way for me
to make it to another candle. After my kidnapping, I was transferred
from North Ossetia to Chechnya, three days of slow travel
in the trunks of different cars, and upon arrival, I was interrogated for 11 days by a guy called Ruslan. The routine was always the same: a bit more light, 45 minutes. He would come down to the cellar, he would ask the guards
to tie me on the chair, and he would turn on the music loud, and then he would yell questions. He would scream. He would beat me. I’ll spare you the details. There are many questions
I could not understand, and there are some questions
I did not want to understand. The length of the interrogation
was the duration of the tape: 15 songs, 45 minutes. I would always long for the last song. On one day, one night in that cellar,
I don’t know what it was, I heard a child crying above my head, a boy, maybe two or three years old. Footsteps, confusion, people running. So when Ruslan came the day after, before he put the first question to me, I asked him, “How is your son today?
Is he feeling better?” Ruslan was taken by surprise. He was furious that the guards
may have leaked some details about his private life. I kept talking about NGOs
supplying medicines to local clinics that may help his son to get better,
and we talked about education. We talked about families. He talked to me about his children. I talked to him about my daughters. And then he’d talk about guns,
about cars, about women, and I had to talk about guns,
about cars, about women. And we talked until
the last song on the tape. Ruslan was the most brutal man I ever met. He did not touch me anymore. He did not ask any other questions. I was no longer just a commodity. Two days after, I was transferred
to another place. There, a guard came to me, very close, it’s quite unusual, and with a very soft voice, he said, “I’d like to thank you for the assistance your organization
provided my family when we were displaced
in nearby Dagestan.” What could I possibly reply? It was so painful.
It was like a blade in the belly. It took me weeks of internal thinking to try to reconcile the good reasons
we had to assist that family and the soldier of fortune he became. He was young, he was shy. I never saw his face. He probably meant well. But in those 15 seconds, he made me question everything we did, all the sacrifices. He made me think also how they see us. Until then, I had assumed
that they know why we are there and what we are doing. One cannot assume this. Well, explaining why we do this
is not that easy, even to our closest relatives. We are not perfect, we are not superior, we are not the world’s fire brigade, we are not superheroes, we don’t stop wars, we know that humanitarian response is not a substitute
for a political solution. Yet we do this because one life matters. Sometimes that’s the only
difference you make, one individual, one family,
a small group of individuals, and it matters. When you have a tsunami,
an earthquake, or a typhoon, you see teams of rescuers
coming from all over the world, searching for survivors for weeks. Why? Nobody questions this. Every life matters, or every life should matter. This is the same for us
when we help refugees, people displaced within their country
by conflict, or stateless persons. I know many people, when they are confronted
with overwhelming suffering, they feel powerless, and they stop there. It’s a pity, because there are
so many ways people can help. We don’t stop with that feeling. We try to do whatever we can
to provide some assistance, some protection, some comfort. We have to. We can’t do otherwise. It makes us feel, I don’t know,
simply, human. After my release — That’s a picture of me
the day of my release. I can see in your faces
you don’t like my look. (Laughter) But with all due respect, when I watch TV these days, I find myself quite trendy on that one. (Laughter) Months after my release,
I met the then-French Prime Minister. The second thing he told me, he said, “You were totally irresponsible
to go to the North Caucasus. You don’t know how many
problems you’ve created for us.” (Laughter) It was a short meeting. (Laughter) I think helping people
in danger is responsible. In that war, that nobody
seriously wanted to stop, and we have many of these today, bringing some assistance to people in need
and a bit of protection was not just an act of humanity, it was making a real difference
for the people. Why could he not understand this? We have a responsibility to try. You’ve heard about that concept:
Responsibility to Protect. Outcomes may depend on various parameters. We may even fail,
but there is worse than failing, it’s not even trying when we can. Well, if you are made this way,
if you sign up for this sort of job, your life is going to be full
of joy and sadness, because there are a lot of people
we cannot help, a lot of people we cannot protect,
a lot of people we did not save. I call them my ghosts, and by having witnessed
their suffering from close, you take a bit of that suffering
on yourself. Many young humanitarian workers go through their first experience
with a lot of bitterness. They are thrown into situations
where they are witness, but they are powerless
to bring any change. They have to learn to accept it and gradually turn this
into positive energy. It’s difficult. Many don’t succeed. But for those who do,
there is no other job like this. You can see the difference
you make every day. Humanitarian aid workers
know the risk they are taking in conflict areas or in post-conflict
environments, yet our life, our job, is becoming
increasingly life-threatening, and the sanctity of our life is fading. Do you know that since the millennium, the number of attacks
on humanitarian aid workers has tripled? 2013 broke new records: 155 colleagues killed, 171 seriously wounded, 134 abducted. So many broken lives. Until the beginning of the civil war
in Somalia in the late ’80s, humanitarian aid workers
were sometimes victims of what we call collateral damages, but by and large, we were not
the target of these attacks. This has changed. Look at these pictures. Baghdad, August 2003: 24 colleagues were killed. Gone are the days
when the U.N. blue flag or Red Cross would automatically protect us. Criminal groups and some political groups have cross-fertilized
over the last 20 years, and they’ve created this sort of hybrids with whom we have no way of communicating. Humanitarian principles are tested,
questioned, and often ignored. But perhaps more importantly,
we have abandoned the search for justice. There seems to be
no consequence whatsoever for attacks against
humanitarian aid workers. After my release, I was told
not to seek any form of justice. “It won’t do any good to you.” That’s what I was told. “Plus, you’re going to put in danger
the life of other colleagues.” It took me years to see the sentencing of three people associated
with my kidnapping, but this was the exception. There was no justice
for any of the humanitarian aid workers killed or abducted
in Chechnya between ’95 and ’99, and it’s the same all over the world. This is unacceptable. This is inexcusable. Attacks on humanitarian aid workers
are war crimes in international law. Those crimes should not go unpunished. We must end this cycle of impunity. We must consider that those attacks
against humanitarian aid workers are attacks against humanity itself. That makes me furious. I know I’m very lucky,
compared to the refugees I work for. I don’t know what it is to have seen
my whole town destroyed. I don’t know what it is to have seen
my relatives shot in front of me. I don’t know what it is to lose
the protection of my country. I also know that I’m very lucky
compared to other hostages. Four days before my eventful release,
four hostages were beheaded a few miles away from where
I was kept in captivity. Why them? Why am I here today? No easy answer. I was received with a lot of support
that I got from my relatives, from colleagues, from friends,
from people I didn’t know. They have helped me over years
to come out of the darkness. Not everyone was treated
with the same attention. How many of my colleagues,
after a traumatic incident, took their own life? I can count nine that I knew personally. How many of my colleagues
went through a difficult divorce after a traumatic experience, because they could not explain
anything anymore to their spouse? I’ve lost that count. There is a price for this type of life. In Russia, all war monuments have
this beautiful inscription at the top. It says, (In Russian) “Nikto ne zabyt,
nichto ne zabyto.” (In English) No one is forgotten,
nothing is forgotten. I do not forget my lost colleagues. I cannot forget anything. I call on you to remember their dedication and demand that humanitarian
aid workers around the world be better protected. We should not let that light of hope
they have brought to be switched off. After my ordeal,
a lot of colleagues asked me, “But why do you continue? Why do you do this sort of job? Why do you have to go back to it?” My answer was very simple. If I had quit — that would have meant
my kidnapper had won. They would have taken my soul and my humanity. Thank you. (Applause)

6 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *